The aftermath of Self Defence part 2 – Arrested.

The aftermath of Self Defence part 2 – Arrested.

Think you got it covered?

If you get arrested for defending yourself, how do you handle the questions that follow?

This blog follows on from ‘Arrested after defending yourself, what should you do?’

For the most part the police are doing a difficult job with a high degree of professionalism and it is important to point out that the police are not the enemy. However if you have been physically attacked and have been forced to use self defence to protect yourself, and as a result the other person (the attacker) is injured, or worse, the police who attend the scene will have two basic jobs to do:

1. Investigate the incident to find out what happened

2. Gather evidence that may be later used in court.

You may be spoken to by police at the scene or at a police station and they will often employ tactics to find out what happened and gather evidence. Remember, police have been trained extensively in interviewing techniques and many, especially detectives, are extremely skilled and effective.

In other cases police may use none of these interviewing strategies and simply ask you if you wish to be interviewed or make a statement. If this is the case a simple “No” will suffice. Remember if you are involved in an incident you may be in some degree of shock and you will be scared/nervous and possibly intimidated by the situation.

Some tactics that might be employed by police include:

1:         Bullying and intimidation.

It is hoped that this sort of tactic is not used outside of TV cop shows, however if you feel intimidated into making a confession by comments such as “things will be much worse for you if you don’t give a statement”, or “you won’t get bail unless you tell us what happened”, it is important to stand your ground and heed the advice from the January 2014 article.

2:         Telling your side of the story.

This is very clever as the police will appear to be on your side. As I said, they are not the enemy, however likewise they are not on your side.  They are on the side of gathering evidence, maybe against you to potentially secure a conviction. What you may hear is, “we just need to get your side of the story”, or “it’s important to get your version otherwise we just have to go with that other people have said”.

3:         You can tell me everything; I am your new best friend.

Similar to tactic 2, this is about building rapport and trust with you, but just like tactic 2, it is about gathering evidence. You may hear; “Mate I am here to help you but I can’t do that unless you tell me exactly what happened” or “you will feel so much better when you get this off your chest and then we can help you”. Remember you do not have to say anything at this stage. You do not have to agree to be video interviewed, provide a statement or to write anything down.

You are protected from prosecution if you have acted in self defence and your behaviour or response to the attack was necessary and your conduct was a reasonable response in the circumstances as you perceived them.

When dealing with police it is important to remember that they are people just like you only they are doing a difficult job. Be polite, do not physically resist if they advise you that you are being arrested and comply with their directions as this may be for your own safety.

Another important piece of advice is not to brag that you have martial art training. This may create a picture of you that will not help your case down the line and may also be seized upon by the media if the incident or the injuries to the other person are serious.

The author of this post, Phil O’Brien is a solicitor with Sydney firm Teddington Legal and a martial arts instructor who has taught reality based self defence in Western Sydney for the past twenty five years, he has extensively studied both the physical and psychological elements of self defence.

Should you require the services of a solicitor in regard to the use of self defence or any other legal matters, Phil can be contacted at or via or directly on 0409 078 322


This is general information only; it does not replace advice from a qualified solicitor in your state or territory.  It is recommended that should require legal advice you should seek advice from a suitability qualified and experience legal practitioner in your state.



Share this


Add your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Penrith Self Defence & Bukido Martial Arts

Penrith Self Defence & Bukido Martial Arts